tiki

Nado Natterings
Back to Islandersports

A weekly column by David Axelson

Nado Natterings
by David Axelson, Chief Executive Officer
The Islander Sports Foundation

 
17 Sept 2008 Issue No. 35


With Islander Football experiencing a bye week; CHS Boys Water Polo scrimmaging twice, but not beginning their regular season until this coming weekend; and the Boys and Girls Cross Country Teams in training, but not in meets; this would figure to be a slow news week.

Au contraire, as we still have Girls Tennis, Girls Golf, Girls Volleyball (picking up the trend yet?) and some CHS Sailing to cover. We’ll also riff on the Chargers at the conclusion of this column, as we investigate whether or not corner back Warren Cromartie committed another personal foul or four boarding the team bus on the way to the airport after Sunday’s game in Denver.

CHS Girls Tennis Takes Two Matches Last Week

The Islander Girls Tennis program, under the direction of Head Coach Rob LeBuhn had a nice week as they defeated Point Loma Monday by the game score of 12-6, followed by a 15-3 victory over Hilltop Tuesday.

LeBuhn plans to have his normal singles roster include No. 1 Jackie Hites, No. 2 Spencer Berman, and No. 3 Mary Mulvey. The doubles teams will consist of No. 1 Brittany Hites and Jennifer Carney, No. 2 Alex Rawlings and Kirsten Krock and No. 3 Andrea Sassenrath and Natalie Brooks.

Coronado competed last week without the services Hites the Younger, a freshman and their No. 1 singles player, who had an injured calf. LeBuhn then had to juggle the lineup. Berman moved into the No. 1 singles slot and won four of her six sets during the week. Katlyn McCue and Jordan Vaughan both played No. 2 in one match each and Rawlings played No. 3 singles against Point Loma. The strength of the team last week was found on the doubles side, as Carney/Hites the Elder, Sassenrath/Brooks and Sara Moore/Krock won all six of their matches for the week.

A total of 33 players came out for tennis this season, with 16 players on the varsity and 17 on the JV. According to LeBuhn, a total of four freshmen are on the varsity, with three of the underclassmen (Hites, Mulvey and Rawlings) earning their way into the starting lineup.

The Islanders will again compete in the hyper-competitive Western League, which includes Our Lady of Peace, Scripps Ranch, La Jolla, Cathedral Catholic and University City. With the infusion of young talent to the roster, the Islanders appear to be much improved, but figure to be looking up at most of their Western League foes when the season standings are finalized.

Despite long-standing local tennis power La Jolla being in the Western League lineup again this year, LeBuhn thinks that Cathedral Catholic will be the team to beat in the league race. Unfortunately, the CIF Division III playoff rosters include both La Jolla, Cathedral and La Jolla Country Day, who defeated Coronado 16-2 in a meeting earlier this season. Coronado has a 2-1 record this season.

This week the Islanders host Canyon Crest Academy, another potential Division III playoff opponent at Coronado at 3:15 pm Tuesday.

Islander Girls Golf Also Wins Two Matches Last Week

The Islanders Girls Golf Team had one tough match last week and one that didn’t prove to be difficult and Coronado proved to be victorious in both.

Tuesday the Islanders warmed up with San Diego High School and emerged with a 288-350 victory (low score wins). Coronado was led by team Captain Lety Buil-MacCarty, who shot a 56 and the next five Coronado players were within four shots of her.

Then Thursday it was time to get serious as Coronado hosted Our Lady of Peace, a team which had posted a fine score of 239 earlier in the season. The Islanders emerged with a close 253-256 victory. Jackie Davis was the match medalist with a 45, followed by Mackenzie Coutts and Bridgett Nielsen, both with 49’s. Senior newcomer Joy Jamison shot a 54, which pleased Coach Randy Coutts. “I think we’ll see her under 50 (for nine holes) pretty soon. She hits the ball really well, but she hasn’t played a lot. Once she figures out how to manage the game, she is going to be quite a player for us.”Buil-MacCarty and Ashley Mendham both shot 56 to complete the scoring against OLP.

Wednesday Coronado hosts Crawford and Coaches Coutts and Hanna Cohan will field several different players. “We’ll take the girls who only have one match under their belts and they will play against Crawford,” said Coutts. “That means that after four matches, everyone will have played twice. We’ll take the girls who have proven themselves in those matches and put them in our Top Six.

Girls Volleyball Team Competes in Fall Classic Invitational

Last week we noted that the CHS Girls Volleyball Team was due to compete in the 25-team Fall Classic Invitational. Included in Coronado’s pool were Carlsbad, Valhalla and San Dieguito Academy. Or in order, a very good Division I team, followed by a strong Division II team and a competitive Division III team.

Friday night’s pool play found the Islanders winless against those three schools and Saturday morning Coronado advanced to the Bronze Division, where they faced Eastern League rival Our Lady of Peace in the seeding game. “They handed it to us,” said Head Coach Christina Lahr of the match. “It was a very disappointing loss. (Assistant Coach) Leilani Au Hoon and I know the team can play better than that. We looked like a JV team versus a Varsity team. We weren’t playing together or communicating.”

With a short time between the end of the OLP game and the next game with West Hills, the team met among themselves, followed by a meeting with the coaching staff. “I knew we were asking a lot of them to do a complete 180 from match to match,” Lahr said. “I had never seen our team play like that, either in a game or in practice. It was very shocking.”

Something clicked during the conversations and the Islanders played well against West Hills, a team that went on to the Bronze Division finals. “We came out and played incredibly well,” Lahr said. “We won the first game 25-17. We looked like we had been playing together for years. Our players were excited, talking and working together. Melissa Humphrey had a rough morning and she came out like a completely different setter. Kori Fitzgerald also had a rough morning and she came out and put that all behind her against West Hills. We also started Rachel Rodriguez. Against OLP she was the only player who seemed like she wanted to play. She had an amazing match against West Hills, putting serves and hits in and she had a couple of incredible digs. She fired everybody up.”

Unfortunately the Islanders lost a close second game 25-22, setting up a fourth game, which they narrowly lost and were out of the tournament.

“We know the team can compete in the Eastern League and then go into the CIF,” Lahr said of her team. “They were incredible to watch against West Hills. They definitely were a team on the court in that second match Saturday.”

This week the Islanders host Grossmont on Thursday at 5 pm. Eastern League competition will commence the following week.

CHS Sailing Team Tryouts Underway

The CHS Sailing Team is in the process of holding tryouts and interested parties should contact Head Coach Jon Rogers, who doubles as the head coach at the Coronado Yacht Club. Rogers is a two-time winner of the San Diego Yachtsman of the Year award and was a World Sailing Champion in J-22 and J-24 Keelboats and the Snipe Dinghy.

The CHSST board of directors is actively preparing for the exciting challenges of inventory, fundraising and travel for the coming season. Team Captain and senior Alex Wood is gearing up to lead the team and assist in the fund-raising efforts. The goal for the season is to qualify for the High School Nationals to be sailed in May 2009 in St. Petersburg, Florida.

Chargers Facing Uphill Battle After Blown Call in Denver

Sunday afternoon was spent in ‘Charger Game Mode,’ which consists of a stack of unread back issues of “The Wall Street Journal,” placed immediately adjacent to my black recliner, which in turn is positioned directly in front of the ‘Fitty’ (ask your kids, they’ll know). While perusing “The Journal” (tough week for Lehman Brothers) and watching the game (listen to the original play, watch the replay, back to the financial markets) Your Natterer had a flash back to a football from a long time ago. It was reminiscent of the glory days of the old American Football League with George Blanda in high top black cleats fading back to pass for the Houston Oilers and having his long touchdown pass almost immediately countered by a scoring bomb from the Kansas City Chiefs’ Len Dawson. It was wide-open, pass happy football with plenty of scoring.

Unfortunately, due at least in part to a badly blown call by NFL referee Ed Hochuli, and a more to the point, a porous Bolt defense in the first half, the Chargers lost a game they should have won by the score of 39-38. For a Chargers ownership group, team management and a fan base expecting to go to the Super Bowl, this is the kind of game that can cost a head coach his job.

Typically 10 victories gets a team into the playoffs, although in 2007 the Cleveland Browns reached that double digit victory total and didn’t qualify for the post season. So, to be safe and secure, the Chargers need to win 11 games this year, meaning they have to finish the year 11-3 against a very tough schedule. This was a game that needed to and was supposed to be in the ‘win’ column. It’s this kind of season that the NFL’s unbalanced schedule (better teams play other better teams in their non-divisional contests) makes winning streaks difficult to put together and makes the Chargers’ collective challenge that much tougher.

The call by Hochuli, considered to be one of the game’s best referees, was made on a play where Bronco quarterback Jay Cutler clearly fumbled. But Hochuli, stationed immediately behind Cutler, whistled the play dead as Chargers linebacker Tim Dobbins was making a fine play, supplying the defensive pressure that forced the fumble and then making an athletic play on the recovery. In sports, good plays are supposed to be rewarded and bad plays should cost you the game. Unfortunately this philosophy was turned on its ear in Denver.

The theory behind instant replay is very simple and direct – get the play called correctly. Regardless of the limitations on instant replay in the NFL, the system failed.

Early in the spring, when instant replay was gaining momentum in Major League Baseball, I told the Natter Son that it would take blown calls negatively impacting either of the New York franchises (Yankees or Mets) or the Boston Red Sox for MLB to finally go to instant replay. Within the week, both New York teams lost games due to incorrect fair or foul home runs calls. Lo and behold, MLB now has instant replay.

I have come to another conclusion regarding the NFL and that is that the game’s rules are now too complicated for the casual fan to follow. If an official takes 30 seconds to explain a call to the crowd and the coaching staffs still don’t understand the call, then your rules are too arcane to follow. Players are exempted from this concept because 99 per cent of them don’t read the rule book and thus when they argue a call it is rarely from a technical perspective. Having worked in the NBA for more than a dozen years, trust me the covers on the player’s pristine copy of the rule book supplied at the beginning of each season, doesn’t get cracked.

Now, let’s address to the immediate challenges facing the Chargers as they attempt to salvage their year. Entering the season the five biggest names on the Chargers were running back LaDainian Tomlinson, quarterback Philip Rivers and tight end Antonio Gates on offense along with linebacker Shawne Merriman and tackle Jamal Williams on defense. Merriman is lost for the season to a severe knee injury, with Tomlinson and Gates hobbled with toe injuries. Williams, in his 11th season in the NFL, is also recovering from off-season surgery and isn’t the immense defensive presence he has been in the last couple of years. Rivers alone among the Top Five is having a good year and he can’t carry the load alone. Stars are being replaced by fill-ins and with the possible exception of speed merchant Darren Sproles for Tomlinson, there is a dramatic drop in the talent level.

Notice that none of the five names above included defensive cornerback Antonio Cromartie, who for the first two weeks of the season apparently has focused on setting the NFL record for pass interceptions in a season. Instead Cromartie was whistled for four 15-yard penalties against Denver, an unfathomable total for a single player in one game. In addition when Bronco receiver Brandon Marshall caught 18 passes in the game, several of his receptions were in an around the area patrolled by Cromartie. Warren, stop talking, play the game, and the records may or may not take care of themselves.

In this era of instant gratification and instant blame; when the 24-hour news cycle is reduced to roughly 12 minutes, one of the boldest coaching moves of recent times was made by Bronco Head Coach Mike Shanahan. Trailing by one point with 24 seconds left in the game, the conventional call would be to kick an extra point to tie the score and hope to hang on in overtime. Shanahan called for a two-point conversion to win the game, the ultimate risk/reward call, and a maneuver that paid off handsomely for the home team.

The Chargers playoff chances are dimming daily and the light at the end of the tunnel may be the 3:10 from Yuma and not the torch of playoff victory. Monday Night Football comes to San Diego and the Chargers desperately need to dismantle the New York Jets or they will just be playing out the string for the next 13 games.